If you can't choose not to use a technology, you are not using that technology, it is using you.

@strypey I mean, seriously: Is central heating as bad with that regard as whatever evil digital technology you had in mind?

@Wolf480pl you can choose to turn the central heating off. You'd be really cold and it'd suck, but you could choose to do so. If you couldn't make that choice, then you would be a slave feeding the central heating sequestered carbon to turn into CO2, so pretty evil ;) But yeah, I guess I was thinking more of the obvious contrast between implants and PCs, and the less obvious contrast between mobile internet and the 1990s dial-up net.

@strypey You always have a choice, but the debate shouldn't be about whether that choice is using you or whether the technology requires you to do anything. That is a problematic oversimplification. More importantly what does it add to our lives and what do it cost us? Is that exchange worth it? Does the way we're using the technology matter? What are the moral implications of this exchange, or the specific way of using the technology?

I could for instance choose not to rely on living in a heated house and wearing clothes, but I'd rather not. What I get from that technology is well worth the cost. But I still have the choice, just as with any technology. Of course there are other examples, like medical technology people need to survive. That is also a choice, just a far less attractive choice.

@strypey This is pre-requisite to a coercive contract, and a good sign to watch out for one to be sure!

@strypey otoh there are a lot of technologies that are using me, not because I can't not use them, but because human nature renders not using them an unlikely choice in the face of their prevalence, attention grabbing techniques and general tempting nature.

@feonixrift yup. Pretty much my point ;) The OP was my attempt at a simple rule of thumb I could use to help me identify attempts at attention hacking and resist them. A kind of firewall for the mind.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Mastodon - NZOSS

The social network of the future: No ads, no corporate surveillance, ethical design, and decentralization! Own your data with Mastodon!